Nursing versus Medical Model – Differences and Benefits

Nursing versus Medical Model

Nursing versus Medical Model – In healthcare, the medical model and the nursing model are two approaches that guide the provision of care. The medical model has been the dominant model for centuries, focusing on diagnosing and treating illness or disease. On the other hand, the nursing model is a more recent approach that takes a holistic view of patients, considering their physical, emotional, and social needs.

Understanding these two models is crucial for healthcare professionals, policymakers, and patients alike. In this article, we will explore the differences and benefits of each model, and how they can be integrated for optimal patient care.

Medical Model

A medical model is a traditional approach to healthcare that focuses on diagnosing and treating illness or disease. It is based on the biomedical model of disease, which assumes that illness is caused by specific biological factors, such as pathogens or genetic abnormalities. This model dates back to the 19th century when medical science began to flourish, and it has remained the dominant model of healthcare ever since.

One of the benefits of the medical model is its clear and concise approach to diagnosis and treatment. The model relies on objective measurements and testing to identify and treat illnesses. However, the model is not without its drawbacks. For example, it can be reductionist and may ignore the emotional and social factors that can influence health outcomes.

How Medical Models Used in Healthcare

The medical model is used in healthcare to diagnose and treat diseases and medical conditions based on objective signs and symptoms, laboratory tests, and medical imaging. It emphasizes the physical aspects of the disease and focuses on finding a cure or treatment for the condition.

In the medical model, healthcare professionals, including physicians and specialists, use their knowledge and expertise to diagnose and treat the person’s medical condition. They may prescribe medications, recommend surgeries, or provide other treatments to manage the condition and alleviate symptoms.

The medical model also emphasizes evidence-based practice, where healthcare professionals use scientific research and data to guide their clinical decision-making. This approach ensures that the person receives the most effective and appropriate treatment for their condition.

Nursing Model

The nursing model is a more recent approach to healthcare that takes a holistic view of patients. It considers the whole person, including their physical, emotional, and social needs. In 1965, Dr. Loretta Ford and Dr. Henry Silver defined the basis for a nursing model.

One of the benefits of the nursing model is its focus on patient-centered care. The model considers the patient’s preferences and values and works to develop a care plan that is tailored to their unique needs. However, the model can be criticized for being too subjective and not relying enough on objective measurements.

How Nursing Model Used in Healthcare

The nursing model is used in healthcare to provide patient-centered care that addresses the physical, emotional, and social needs of the person. Nursing models emphasize the person’s subjective experience and the importance of the therapeutic relationship between the nurse and the patient.

One way that the nursing model is used in healthcare is through the nursing process. The nursing process involves five steps: assessment, diagnosis, planning, implementation, and evaluation. Nurses use this process to assess the person’s health status, identify nursing diagnoses, develop a care plan, implement interventions, and evaluate the effectiveness of the care provided.

Another way that the nursing model is used in healthcare is through the use of nursing theories. Nursing theories provide a framework for understanding the role of the nurse in healthcare and guide the development of nursing practice. For example, the Roy Adaptation Model emphasizes the importance of adapting to the person’s needs, while the Orem Self-Care Deficit Theory focuses on the person’s ability to care for themselves.

Differences Between Nursing versus Medical Model

There are several key differences between the nursing and medical models of care. Firstly, the medical model is focused on diagnosing and treating illness or disease, whereas the nursing model is focused on the whole person, considering their physical, emotional, and social needs. Secondly, the medical model is more reductionist and objective, while the nursing model is more holistic and subjective. Finally, the medical model relies on a physician-led approach, while the nursing model values interdisciplinary teamwork.

These differences can impact patient outcomes in significant ways. For example, a patient may receive a correct diagnosis and treatment under the medical model, but not receive adequate support for their emotional and social needs. Alternatively, a patient may receive holistic care under the nursing model, but not receive a timely diagnosis or treatment for their illness.

Advantages and Disadvantages of nursing and medical models

Both the nursing and medical models have their advantages and disadvantages. The medical model is effective in treating many diseases and conditions, and it relies on scientific research and empirical evidence. However, it may not take into account the emotional and social aspects of health, and it may not provide the necessary care for certain patients. The nursing model, on the other hand, is effective in improving patient outcomes and satisfaction, and it takes into account the patient’s emotional and social needs. However, it may not provide the necessary medical interventions for certain diseases and conditions.

In certain situations, one model may be more effective than the other. For example, in the case of a patient with a chronic illness, the nursing model may be more effective because it focuses on the care of the patient as a whole person. However, in the case of a patient with a life-threatening illness, the medical model may be more effective because it focuses on the treatment of the disease.

Integrating the Nursing and Medical Models

The nursing and medical models are two distinct approaches to healthcare, with nursing emphasizing the person’s subjective experience and the medical model focusing on the physiological aspects of the disease. Integrating these two models can provide holistic care that addresses both the physical and emotional needs of the person.

Example of Integrating the Nursing versus Medical Model

One example of successful integration of the nursing and medical models is in the treatment of chronic diseases such as diabetes. Nurses can work with physicians to provide education on self-management techniques, monitor blood sugar levels, and provide emotional support for the person. This collaboration between the two models can help prevent complications and improve the person’s overall health and well-being.

Another example is in the care of older adults. Nurses can assess the person’s functional abilities and work with physicians to develop a care plan that addresses both their medical needs and their functional limitations. This approach can help improve the person’s quality of life and prevent hospital readmissions.

The benefits of Integrating the Nursing versus Medical Model

The benefits of using an integrated approach include improved communication and coordination between healthcare professionals, more personalized care for the person, and improved health outcomes. By working together, nurses and physicians can provide comprehensive care that addresses the person’s physical, emotional, and social needs. This approach can lead to better health outcomes and improved satisfaction for both the person and healthcare providers.

Conclusion -“Nursing Versus Medical Model”

In Nursing Versus Medical Model conclusion, understanding the differences between nursing and medical models is important in providing high-quality patient care. While the medical model focuses on diagnosis and treatment, the nursing model emphasizes holistic care and the patient’s overall well-being. Both models have their advantages and disadvantages, but integrating them can lead to improved patient outcomes. By working together, healthcare providers can provide the best of both worlds, delivering high-quality medical care while also considering the patient’s emotional, mental, and social needs.

As healthcare continues to evolve, it’s important for providers to stay informed and adaptable, incorporating new approaches and techniques as needed. By embracing an integrated approach that combines the strengths of both the nursing and medical models, healthcare providers can deliver the best possible care to their patients.

Care of Rubber Goods in Nursing

Please note that this article is for informational purposes only and should not substitute professional medical advice.

Name -Parika Parika holds a Master's in Nursing and is pursuing a Ph.D. in Nursing. In addition to her clinical experience, Parika has also served as a nursing instructor for the past 10 years, she enjoys sharing her knowledge and passion for the nursing profession.

Leave a Reply

Recent articles


More like this